| Red Sox | B&E Ballers | Maulers | Usual Suspects | Money Shots | Thrashers | Designated Hebrews | Battlin' Blue Sox | Major Load | Sidewinders |
| Ryan Doumit | Russell Martin | Joe Mauer | Chris Snyder | Chris Iannetta | Bengie Molina | Wladimir Balentien | A.J. Pierzynski | Geovany Soto | Dioner Navarro |
| Derrek Lee | Mark Teixeira | Jason Bay | Lance Berkman | Michael Bourn | Adam Jones | 0 | Jay Bruce | Justin Morneau | Gary Sheffield |
| Brian Roberts | Alexi Casilla | Carlos Pena | Lastings Milledge | Jerry Hairston | Adam Dunn | Nelson Cruz | Akinori Iwamura | Ichiro Suzuki | Mark Kotsay |
| Shane Victorino | David Wright | Jorge Cantu | Kevin Youkilis | Ryan Theriot | Brad Hawpe | Alexei Ramirez | Hank Blalock | Aramis Ramirez | Cristian Guzman |
| Michael Young | Jimmy Rollins | Jack Cust | Miguel Tejada | Jacoby Ellsbury | Derek Jeter | Dexter Fowler | Elijah Dukes | Jhonny Peralta | Edgar Renteria |
| Ryan Howard | Carlos Beltran | Orlando Cabrera | Ryan Ludwick | Andy Laroche | Vladimir Guerrero | Josh Hamilton | Brian Giles | Curtis Granderson | Lyle Overbay |
| Bobby Abreu | Alex Rios | David Dejesus | Jason Kubel | Milton Bradley | Chase Utley | Grady Sizemore | Stephen Drew | Albert Pujols | Jim Thome |
| Miguel Cabrera | Ryan Braun | Jose Guillen | Delmon Young | Nick Markakis | Raul Ibanez | Manny Ramirez | Chris Young | Garret Anderson | Troy Glaus |
| Alfonso Soriano | Carlos Quinten | Adam Laroche | Bill Hall | Josh Anderson | Mike Jacobs | Alex Rodriguez | Hunter Pence | Aubrey Huff | Jayson Werth |
| Jose Reyes | James Loney | Jose Lopez | Jason Giambi | Johnny Damon | Vernon Wells | Matt Kemp | Carlos Delgado | Prince Fielder | Kelly Johnson |
| Adrian Gonzalez | Evan Longoria | Xavier Nady | Travis Hafner | Casey Blake | Chone Figgins | David Ortiz | Carlos Gomez | Dustin Pedroia | Placido Polanco |
| Torii Hunter | Andre Ethier | Jermaine Dye | Joey Votto | Denard Span | Magglio Ordonez | Christopher Davis | Nick Swisher | Kevin Kouzmanoff | Mark Derosa |
| Rich Harden | Ryan Rowland-Smith | Mike Pelfrey | James Shields | Tim Lincecum | Gregory Smith | Josh Johnson | Ricky Nolasco | Ryan Dempster | Kenny Rogers |
| Brandon Webb | Justin Verlander | Francisco Liriano | Edinson Volquez | Jonathan Sanchez | Aaron Harang | Daisuke Matsuzaka | Scott Baker | Ted Lilly | Jon Lester |
| Josh Beckett | Armando Galarraga | David Purcey | Matt Garza | Clay Buccholz | Roy Halladay | Nick Adenhart | John Danks | Johan Santana | Cliff Lee |
| Clayton Kershaw | Ervin Santana | Todd Wellemeyer | John Lackey | Jered Weaver | Cole Hamels | Christopher Volstad | Mark Buehrle | Dan Haren | Jair Jurrjens |
| Jonathan Papelbon | Chad Billingsley | Jonathan Broxton | Ryan Franklin | Brad Lidge | Bobby Jenks | Mariano Rivera | B.J. Ryan | Brian Fuentes | Trevor Hoffman |
| James Happ | Zach Miner | Francisco Cordero | Hideki Okajima | Jose Valverde | Brian Wilson | Brandon Morrow | Joakim Soria | Joe Nathan | George Sherrill |
| Victor Martinez | Shaun Marcum | Ty Wigginton | Takashi Saito | Rafael Furcal | Zack Greinke | Trevor Cahill | Yunel Escobar | Zach Duke | Tony Gwynn |
| Salomon Torres | Ryan Garko | Mike Cameron | Jorge Posada | Luke Scott | Yovani Gallardo | Taylor Teagarden | Ubaldo Jimenez | Wily Mo Pena | Tim Hudson |
| Ryan Zimmerman | Philip Hughes | Mark Reynolds | Jeff Kent | Jeff Clement | Troy Tulowitzki | Shin-Soo Choo | Skip Schumaker | Ryan Freel | Scott Rolen |
| Rocco Baldelli | Paul Byrd | Kevin Gregg | Fred Lewis | J.D. Drew | Ramon Vazquez | Robinson Cano | Scott Olsen | Rich Hill | Ryan Church |
| Randy Johnson | Micah Hoffpauir | Joe Saunders | Eric Hinske | Homer Bailey | Rafael Soriano | Mike Aviles | Roy Oswalt | Randy Winn | Rick Ankiel |
| Oliver Perez | Max Scherzer | Joe Blanton | David Murphy | Eugenio Velez | Mike Napoli | Laporta | Pedro Feliz | Paul Maholm | Ramon Hernandez |
| Mike Lowell | Ken Griffey Jr. | Fausto Carmona | Chris Carpenter | Chris Dickerson | Mike Mussina | Kerry Wood | Pat Burrell | Mark Teahen | Melky Cabrera |
| Justin Upton | Jorge Campillo | Edwin Encarnacion | C**k S**ker | Brandon Lyon | Mike Gonzalez | Ian Stewart | Nate Mclouth | Luis Montanez | Juan Pierre |
| Jose Arredondo | Johnny Cueto | Dan Uggla | Bobby Crosby | Ben Sheets | Matt Holliday | Gavin Floyd | Melvin Mora | Livan Hernandez | Joe Crede |
| John Maine | Joba Chamberlain | Chris Young | B.J. Upton | Andrew Miller | Manny Parra | Felix Hernandez | Matt Capps | Kosuke Fukudome | Joe Borowski |
| Jim Edmonds | Jesse Litsch | Billy Butler | Andy Pettitte | * Renewal slot from the Red Sox | Hideki Matsui | Corey Hart | Matt Cain | Khalil Greene | Jason Schmidt |
| Jed Lowrie | Jeremy Guthrie | Aaron Rowand | Adrian Beltre | * Move to Suspects | Glen Perkins | Conor Jackson | M. Wieters | Kazuo Matsui | J.J. Putz |
| Jake Peavy | Jeff Francoeur | Aaron Cook | * Move per week to the Hebrews | Emilio Bonifacio | Christopher Perez | Kyle Lohse | Josh Willingham | Emil Brown | |
| Ian Kinsler | Gil Meche | A.J. Burnett | Clint Barmes | Chad Qualls | Justin Duchscherer | Josh Fields | Dave Bush | ||
| Francisco Rodriguez | David Price | *Switch draft pix in every round with Thrashers | Chipper Jones | Carlos Zambrano | Josh Banks | Jonny Gomes | Coco Crisp | ||
| Brett Myers | Brandon Phillips | *Switch draft pix in every round with Red Sox | Casey Kotchman | Brandon Wood | Jeff Keppinger | Jon Garland | Chad Tracy | ||
| Anibal Sanchez | Brandon Backe | * Renewal slot from the Thrashers | Carlos Guillen | Brad Ziegler | Jarrod Saltalamacchia | Jeremy Hermida | Cameron Maybin | ||
| Andrew McCutcheon | Ben Francisco | * Renewal slot from the Red Sox | Carl Crawford | Adam Wainwright | J.J. Hardy | Javier Vazquez | Blake Dewitt | ||
| *Switch draft pix in every round with Maulers | Anthony Reyes | * Renewal slot from the Major Load | C.C. Sabathia | * Move per week from the Suspects | Huston Street | Jason Isringhausen | Barry Zito | ||
| *Move per week from the Maulers | Adam Lind | * Move per week to the Red Sox | Billy Wagner | Howie Kendrick | Geoff Jenkins | * 2 moves from Ballers | |||
| * Renewal slot to the Money Shots | * Move to Thrashers | Aaron Hill | Gary Matthews Jr. | Fernando Rodney | |||||
| * Renewal slot to the Maulers | * Move to Major Load | *Switch draft pix in every round with Maulers | Freddy Sanchez | Dmitri Young | |||||
| * Move per week to Sidewinders-then-Ballers | * Move per week from Red Sox-then-Sidewinders | * Renewal slot to the Maulers | Dustin McGowan | Chris Duncan | |||||
| * 2 moves to Sidewinders | Derek Lowe | Carlos Marmol | |||||||
| Alex Gordon | Carlos Lee | ||||||||
| * Move to Money Shots w/no refusal | Bronson Arroyo | ||||||||
| Brad Penny | |||||||||
| * Renewal slot to the Maulers | |||||||||
| * Move from Ballers | |||||||||